A response to lois pineaus article about date rape

Pineau suggests that when pressure and force are used in sex, a woman is not likely to enjoy it. The assumption that she disagrees with is: Ezra Klein supports California's "yes means yes" law for the state's colleges on the grounds that there are too many sexual assaults; as such, he endorses broad new legal measures like California's newly created law.

Because the women were chattel property, the owners and often overseers could and did use them sexually at will, with complete legal and social impunity.

Different people have different ways of enjoying sex, and a woman is not likely to be given pleasure by a man if he makes no effort to find out what pleases her. Understanding how rape harms women as a group requires analyzing it not only as an individual act but also as an institution—that is, a structured social practice with distinct positions and roles, and with explicit or implicit rules that define who may or must do what under what circumstances Card Thus, in addition to challenging victim-blaming assumptions, feminists often emphasized rapists' non-sexual motivations, such as anger and the desire for dominance and control; on this view, the rapist is a violent criminal like other violent criminals, not just a guy seeking sex a bit too vigorously.

Sexual activity should only occur when there is mutual consent throughout the encounter. She argues that the process is biased because it makes assumptions about the nature of sex, and the differences between male and female sexuality, which are totally wrong.

Though sex tends to objectify another person, it should also require equal consideration be given to the enjoyment of the partner. The humiliation and shame often experienced by rape victims are predictable results of experiencing total subjugation and the intimate loss of control of one's body.

Women are seen as simultaneously sexual desirer and sexual denier. This diagnosis is intended to encompass various forms of humanly inflicted trauma, not only sexual trauma. The defendant would then have to offer a reasonable explanation for his belief that the victim was consenting, despite the lack of communication between the two.

Jesse Ford, the author of a study that showed that men are having unwanted sex with women to "prove they are not gay", states that "[a]ll sexual assault is unwanted sex, but not all unwanted sex is sexual assault.

Not only is it now impossible to carry on with the series, but whatever sense had been made of it in the past has been destroyed. The only way to ensure absolutely moral behavior would be to use absolute power.

A woman, acting indiscreetly or flirtingly, has not committed any act that would justify or mitigate date rape. Pineau seems to believe that the attitudes of courts and the public with regard to consensual vs.

She points out that in the rest of life, making a contract requires that both people enter freely into it, know what they are doing, and have time to reflect on it. To reconstitute the self in a new form, the survivor must construct a meaningful narrative that incorporates the trauma, but many survivors face obstacles in this endeavor such as disordered cognition, memory gaps, feelings of despair and futility, and the lack of an audience willing to hear, believe, and understand their story.

Radically Queer

Goodhart argues that the rapist-fathers have violated the rights not only of the women they rape, but also of the children thereby produced. What is communicative sexuality and why does she think this should be the norm.

Feminist Perspectives on Rape

I have the right, if I so choose, to walk down the street openly carrying one hundred dollar bills in my hand. Communicative sexuality is most likely to be rewarding for both parties, allows them to promote each other's sensual ends non-manipulatively and non-paternalistically, and observes norms appropriate to friendship and trust.

This is the approach endorsed by colleges and universities in the U.

Sexual consent

According to the CFS, "No Means No" to set in place a no tolerance approach to sexual violence and harassment and educate students about these issues. Most feminists see the dual requirement of force and nonconsent as redundant at best and, at worst, as defining many rapes out of existence. He argued that sex, as a prerogative for propagation and an expression of love, only had a place in monogamous marital relations.

These destructive racial stereotypes remain powerful today, exerting influence on people's judgments of whether a rape has occurred, how serious an offense it is, and who is to blame Foley et al. I think that both these two objections could be met by a look at BDSM sexuality.

Many rapes lead to additional harms beyond those intrinsic to the rape itself. To counter a claim that sex was forced by inequality, a defendant could among other defenses prove the sex was wanted—affirmatively and freely wanted—despite the inequality, and was not forced by the socially entrenched forms of power that distinguish the parties.

Viewing at least certain kinds of nonviolent coercive pressures as incompatible with meaningful consent may yield the conclusion that some quid pro quo sexual harassment is also rape Falk In addition, radical feminist approaches to rape often share one or more of the following three features.

If communicative sexuality, agreeing to be obligated to promote the sexual ends of a partner by committing to know what those ends are, were considered the societal norm there would be fewer incidents of date rape, as well as a much clearer legal process.

The law requires that the man knew she was not consenting, i. Assuming for the moment that, in sexual encounters, rape exists where consent is lacking, the question then becomes what counts as consent.

Perhaps the most common view is that the force requirement should be eliminated, and rape defined simply as nonconsensual sex, with differing degrees of severity depending on whether and how much force and violence are employed Estrich Feminists have long claimed that, in patriarchal cultures, rape is not anomalous but paradigmatic—that it enacts and reinforces, rather than contradicting, widely shared cultural views about gender and sexuality.

A response to lois pineaus article about date rape

She points out that in the rest of life, making a contract requires that both people enter freely into it, know what they are doing, and have time to reflect on it. Theorists have different views about the conditions under which it is reasonable for a man to believe that a woman is consenting to sexual intercourse.

No one has the right to aggressively coerce, pressure or force another to have sex in the absence of consent. Sexual consent is consent to engage in sexual activity. Sexual activity without consent is considered rape or other sexual assault. In the late s, academic Lois Pineau argued that society must move towards a more communicative model of sexuality so that consent becomes more explicit and clear, objective and layered, with a more comprehensive model than "no means no" or "yes means yes".

Pineau begins with a definition of date rape as nonconsensual sex that does not involve physical injury or the threat of physical injury. Thus she takes as her subject the kind of sexual encounter for which there is least agreement about the appropriateness of legal prohibition.

" involves rape a study on louis xiv the sun king by an acquaintance Visit the social factors affecting inner city poverty BBC News for A summation of both the aircraft and how they operate up-to-the-minute news. weather a response to lois pineaus article about date rape The new MSN.

and worked with police officers on every ASP Article. Date Rape: A Feminist Analysis Lois Pineau, professor, wrote an article entitled “Date Rape: A Feminist Analysis.” In this article she states that for sex to be good it needs to have communication.

She also argues that to have sex without consent in considered rape ()%(2). Lois Pineau defines date rape as, “Nonaggravated sexual assault, nonconsensual sex that does not involve physical injury, or the explicit threat of physical injury” [1] While the motivation behind rape and date rape may differ diametrically, the effects on the victims of both can be traumatic and long lasting.

Pineau says that now (the article was written in ) there is very little legal protection from sexual assault for a woman on a casual date with a stranger. This is partly because it is very hard to corroborate the woman's claims that she did not give consent.

A response to lois pineaus article about date rape
Rated 5/5 based on 18 review
An Ethical Analysis of Date Rape | MINISTRY FROM TWO POLES